S.T. Erlewine | allmusic.com

The Bea­t­les White Album

Each song on the sprawl­ing dou­ble album The Bea­t­les is an entity to itself, as the band touches on any­thing and every­thing it can. This makes for a frus­trat­ingly scat­ter­shot record or a sin­gu­larly grip­ping musi­cal expe­ri­ence, depend­ing on your view, but what makes the so-called White Album inter­est­ing is its mess. Never before had a rock record been so self-reflective, or so ironic; the Beach Boys send-up “Back in the U.S.S.R.” and the British blooze par­ody “Yer Blues” are deliv­ered straight-faced, so it’s never clear if these are affec­tion­ate trib­utes or wicked satires. Lennon turns in two of his best bal­lads with “Dear Pru­dence” and “Julia”; scours the Abbey Road vaults for the musique con­crète col­lage “Rev­o­lu­tion 9″; pours on the schmaltz for Ringo’s clos­ing num­ber, “Good Night”; cel­e­brates the Bea­t­les cult with “Glass Onion”; and, with “Cry Baby Cry,” rivals Syd Bar­rett. McCart­ney doesn’t reach quite as far, yet his songs are stun­ning — the music hall romp “Honey Pie,” the mock coun­try of “Rocky Rac­coon,” the ska-inflected “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da,” and the proto-metal roar of “Hel­ter Skelter.”

Clearly, the Bea­t­les’ two main song­writ­ing forces were no longer on the same page, but nei­ther were George and Ringo. Har­ri­son still had just two songs per LP, but it’s clear from “While My Gui­tar Gen­tly Weeps,” the canned soul of “Savoy Truf­fle,” the haunt­ing “Long, Long, Long,” and even the silly “Pig­gies” that he had devel­oped into a song­writer who deserved wider expo­sure. And Ringo turns in a delight with his first orig­i­nal, the lum­ber­ing country-carnival stomp “Don’t Pass Me By.” None of it sounds like it was meant to share album space together, but some­how The Bea­t­les cre­ates its own style and sound through its mess.



Review: by Thomas Erlewine | allmusic.com
Octo­ber, 2005